On March 10, 2003, while performing in London, Natalie Maines of the Dixie Chicks said that the group was "ashamed the President of the United States is from Texas." This singular quote sparked so much controversy that it nearly ended their whole career. The country group was Blacklisted throughout the country music industry. People in Texas burned their CDs and Merchandise. All of this over the lead vocalist of the group expressing her disapproval of the President of the United States.
This quote also was connected to the group's disapproval of the United States Entering into war with Iraq after the terrorist attack on 9/11. With the rise of nationalism in the United States after 9/11, any criticism of the government seemed dangerously un-American. It was a wildly unpopular opinion at the time to hold, some went as far as to say it was treason.
The mainstream country put an entire blockade on the Dixie Chicks music, taking them off the radio, destroying albums, and booing them at the Academy of Country Music Awards. The Dixie Chick, however, did not go silent. They instead went on to do some tour dates to raise money for Bush's opponent in the 2004 election and continued to make music.
Natalie Maines quote never brought her into the Supreme Court, but it goes to show how unpopular speech and criticism of the government is still protected under the First Amendment. Censorship of unpopular opinions can be done without the Government, but it is not going to stop these thoughts from appearing.
Another country music star, Jason Isabel, noted that the Dixie Chicks already had to fight for their place in popular country music, so the reason they were so quickly "cancelled" and blacklisted is because they are women. They had a very specific image of being women in country music, so when they stepped out of that image and criticized a man who was so celebrated by their country fan base, it was entirely outrageous. Even though male country artist like Eric Church, also openly criticize the NRA and the Republican Party.
The Dixie Chick's stance about the Iraq war and the former president may have caused them to be blacklisted by mainstream country music outlets, but the group has continued to remain popular, relevant, and making powerful, female lead music. They went on to win a Grammy for their song Not Ready to Make Nice, which directly references this instance of speaking out against the Iraq war.
Brenna, I found your blogpost extremely interesting as I had never heard about this. I am vaguely familiar with the Dixie Chicks but would have never known that one statement almost made them lose their career. I think it really goes to show how much influence people in the spotlight have and how afraid people are of women speaking out. More specifically, how afraid people are of other people with differing opinions. What did the country music business expect to happen? The lead singer of the Dixie Chicks was going to single handedly impeach the president at the time and also pull all the troops out of war? That’s not realistic. She was just expressing her opinion. I think trying to silence the Dixie Chicks by taking them off radio stations and booing them just made the Dixie Chicks want to fight harder for what they care about. I really liked that in this blogpost you included the efforts the Dixie Chicks made even after the country music industry tried to tear them down. The concerts they put on to raise money as well as going on to win a Grammy shows just how dedicated and strong those women are. I am very glad that they didn’t let people with more “power” silence them or their career.
ReplyDelete